“I’ve had a rough day. I DESERVE this ice cream!”“I can’t stop until all the food is gone.”“I am a Stress Eater.”
How often do you eat for reasons that have little to do with actual physical hunger?Have you ever gone on a diet because your life felt out of control?
It goes without saying that people with eating problems—from the under-weight teen to the overweight grandmother—are not good at reading their body’s signals.At some point in their lives they lost touch with, or stopped trusting, the wisdom of their bodies.
Even many people without eating disorders struggle with this concept.We view our bodies as The Problem, in need of sculpting, injecting, liposucking, starving and perfecting.We seek diet gurus, appetite suppressants and surgeons to help us conquer our appetites.
We don’t think it wise to listen to our guts.The misconception is, “If I listen to my gut I will weigh 400 pounds!”Well, listening to your gut means stopping when your gut is satisfied and not eating for emotional reasons.
Oh.
An overweight Brigham Young professor, Steven Hawks, lost 50 pounds by eating intuitively.His big secret?He only ate when he was hungry, he ate what he truly craved (even if it was ice cream for dinner) and stopped when he was physiologically satisfied.CNN’s Soledad O’Brian interviewed him, asking incredulously, “You mean you just eat when you’re hungry and stop when you’re full?Wow.That sounds REALLY hard!”
So how can we implement the professor’s simple principles?There are three steps:
1. Differentiating between physical and emotional hungers
The other day my 13-year-old stated, “I’m hungry!” Then he paused and added, “Actually, I’m not really hungry.I’m bored!”I was thrilled that he was able to make this subtle distinction. Boredom and stress are the most common reasons for mindless eating.(I contend we could eliminate the obesity epidemic today if people stopped using food to cure boredom and stress.)
So if your child asks for food but you suspect she’s not actually hungry, you might say something like, “Let’s think about this. Go down inside your body.Is your TUMMY hungry or are you feeling something else?”If she can’t answer right away, offer suggestions: “Are you bored?Is there anything else you are feeling?”
2. OK, so you got to a non-hunger feeling.Now what?
A lot of times just by naming the feeling, you can figure out what you (or your child) actually needs.Sad?You may need a good cry.Angry? You may need to speak up.Nervous?See if you need to push through the fear or run the other way!
Before you try to talk your kid out of a bad feeling (a natural instinct to make bad feelings go away) take a moment to empathize first: “Oh, that feels yucky” or “I can understand why you might feel that way.”Sometimes that’s all that is needed to feel okay!The better you are at responding to feelings directly, the less likely these feelings will be stuffed, avoided or numbed with food or dieting.
3.Dealing with Hunger/Fullness.
Hunger is much easier to discern than Satisfied.Some of us keep our tanks topped off all day long so we never actually feel hungry!It’s OK to feel hunger before you eat; ever notice how much more delicious food tastes when you are hungry?
Unfortunately many of us view “Satisfied” as a yellow light and don’t slam on the brakes until “Stuffed.”We inhale our food so there isn’t time for Stomach to let Brain know that the food has arrived.The smells, tastes, visual impact, social atmosphere, conversation, the TV, are all distractions.Your brain’s happy-centers are all screaming, “Yee-Hah! Keep that pleasure a-comin’!”Meanwhile, your belly is whispering in the tornado: “I’m good. You can stop now.”
Huh?Did you hear something?
So become a Belly Whisperer.Once you trust the system which has kept humans trim for millions of years, then you’ll have more faith in your kids’ tummies.It may mean feeding them their big meal when they get off the bus or letting them have a snack before bed.I realize this is a controversial approach.Many of us have strong traditions about feeding our families: three meals a day; eat what the grown-ups eat; no snacking; something green at every meal; clean your plate before dessert; kitchen is closed after dinner.I do not mean to imply that these rules lead to eating disorders.But I am also a fan of flexibility: it’s okay to compromise if the old system doesn’t work for your child’s body.
So, Raise Your Right Hand and Repeat after Me:
M.O.D. Squad (moms of daughters) Principle #2:
I will encourage my child to honor the wisdom of her body by helping her differentiate the needs of her stomach from the needs of her heart. I will help her respect her body’s hunger and fullness signals and I will teach her through my words and deeds healthy, effective ways to cope with difficult feelings.
####
Disclaimer #1: These principles apply to Dads and sons as well.
Disclaimer #2: An eating disorder is not a choice.It is a mental disorder caused by a complex combination of genetic, personality, familial, social and cultural influences.#
“I’ve had a rough day. I DESERVE this ice cream!”“I can’t stop until all the food is gone.”“I am a Stress Eater.”
How often do you eat for reasons that have little to do with actual physical hunger?Have you ever gone on a diet because your life felt out of control?
It goes without saying that people with eating problems—from the under-weight teen to the overweight grandmother—are not good at reading their body’s signals.At some point in their lives they lost touch with, or stopped trusting, the wisdom of their bodies.
Even many people without eating disorders struggle with this concept.We view our bodies as The Problem, in need of sculpting, injecting, liposucking, starving and perfecting.We seek diet gurus, appetite suppressants and surgeons to help us conquer our appetites.
We don’t think it wise to listen to our guts.The misconception is, “If I listen to my gut I will weigh 400 pounds!”Well, listening to your gut means stopping when your gut is satisfied and not eating for emotional reasons.
Oh.
An overweight Brigham Young professor, Steven Hawks, lost 50 pounds by eating intuitively.His big secret?He only ate when he was hungry, he ate what he truly craved (even if it was ice cream for dinner) and stopped when he was physiologically satisfied.CNN’s Soledad O’Brian interviewed him, asking incredulously, “You mean you just eat when you’re hungry and stop when you’re full?Wow.That sounds REALLY hard!”
So how can we implement the professor’s simple principles?There are three steps:
1. Differentiating between physical and emotional hungers
The other day my 13-year-old stated, “I’m hungry!” Then he paused and added, “Actually, I’m not really hungry.I’m bored!”I was thrilled that he was able to make this subtle distinction. Boredom and stress are the most common reasons for mindless eating.(I contend we could eliminate the obesity epidemic today if people stopped using food to cure boredom and stress.)
So if your child asks for food but you suspect she’s not actually hungry, you might say something like, “Let’s think about this. Go down inside your body.Is your TUMMY hungry or are you feeling something else?”If she can’t answer right away, offer suggestions: “Are you bored?Is there anything else you are feeling?”
2. OK, so you got to a non-hunger feeling.Now what?
A lot of times just by naming the feeling, you can figure out what you (or your child) actually needs.Sad?You may need a good cry.Angry? You may need to speak up.Nervous?See if you need to push through the fear or run the other way!
Before you try to talk your kid out of a bad feeling (a natural instinct to make bad feelings go away) take a moment to empathize first: “Oh, that feels yucky” or “I can understand why you might feel that way.”Sometimes that’s all that is needed to feel okay!The better you are at responding to feelings directly, the less likely these feelings will be stuffed, avoided or numbed with food or dieting.
3.Dealing with Hunger/Fullness.
Hunger is much easier to discern than Satisfied.Some of us keep our tanks topped off all day long so we never actually feel hungry!It’s OK to feel hunger before you eat; ever notice how much more delicious food tastes when you are hungry?
Unfortunately many of us view “Satisfied” as a yellow light and don’t slam on the brakes until “Stuffed.”We inhale our food so there isn’t time for Stomach to let Brain know that the food has arrived.The smells, tastes, visual impact, social atmosphere, conversation, the TV, are all distractions.Your brain’s happy-centers are all screaming, “Yee-Hah! Keep that pleasure a-comin’!”Meanwhile, your belly is whispering in the tornado: “I’m good. You can stop now.”
Huh?Did you hear something?
So become a Belly Whisperer.Once you trust the system which has kept humans trim for millions of years, then you’ll have more faith in your kids’ tummies.It may mean feeding them their big meal when they get off the bus or letting them have a snack before bed.I realize this is a controversial approach.Many of us have strong traditions about feeding our families: three meals a day; eat what the grown-ups eat; no snacking; something green at every meal; clean your plate before dessert; kitchen is closed after dinner.I do not mean to imply that these rules lead to eating disorders.But I am also a fan of flexibility: it’s okay to compromise if the old system doesn’t work for your child’s body.
So, Raise Your Right Hand and Repeat after Me:
M.O.D. Squad (moms of daughters) Principle #2:
I will encourage my child to honor the wisdom of her body by helping her differentiate the needs of her stomach from the needs of her heart. I will help her respect her body’s hunger and fullness signals and I will teach her through my words and deeds healthy, effective ways to cope with difficult feelings.
####
Disclaimer #1: These principles apply to Dads and sons as well.
Disclaimer #2: An eating disorder is not a choice.It is a mental disorder caused by a complex combination of genetic, personality, familial, social and cultural influences.#
What you say, as far as it goes, I agree with. However, psychological factors underlying eating disorders run deep. The emotions untended by eating rise up with great force. Containing, understanding and working with those feelings is the basis of eating disorder recovery work.
Intuitive eating, as you recommend and I agree, is the most healthy way
to eat. If a person can recognize such feelings as boredom being the real need and address those feelings without using food, well and good.
People with eating disorders use eating or not eating to cope with what they cannot bear. Intuitive eating releases those unbearable feelings.
Hopefully, a person is in therapy or reaches out for therapy at that stage.
Thank you for bringing up the subject.
Joanna Poppink, MFT
Los Angeles psychotherapist
eating disorder recovery
Hi Joanna! I know you...and your great work. Thanks for your comments.
I agree with you on all fronts~ My hope is that moms reading this column will help their kids develop these emotional coping skills to help ward off a potential eating disorder... We live in a culture which encourages us to shut up feelings, repress them, ignore them, get over them.... despite the fact that feelings provide us with useful information! It's using this information from one part of the brain, and integrating it with the "rational" side of the the brain, which helps kids (and then teens/adults) know themselves better and learn best how to respond to life's difficulties in positive, adaptive ways.
Dear Dina,
You are so right on in what you say here. You are speaking to the core issues in eating disorder prevention.
Interesting how, in the early parenting years, it can come down to respecting the child's experience, opinions, feelings and perspectives.
When we listen to our children with caring AND respect they learn to listen, care and respect themselves. Thisdoesn't provide much opportunity for an eating disorder to develop and provides a terrific inner environment for intuitive eating.
I'm so glad you are presenting this important information in this easy to read and find format.
warm regards and Happy New Year.
Joanna
The Grass Is Greener Right
Here
With her trademark wisdom, humor and honesty, Diana Keough provides a spiritual
antidote to anxiety and despair in increasingly fraught times.
Spirit Behind the News
Ben Kamin is one of America's best-known rabbis, a multi-cultural spiritualist,
New York Times Op-ed contributor, national columnist, and the author of seven
books on human values. His kids, however, are not that impressed.
Love, Sex &
Marriage
Gerald Drose, Ph.D. leads an open discussion on sex-and the other two things
that typically accompany it—love and marriage.
I Kid You
Not
With a self-deprecating sense of humor, a dash of Midwest sarcasm, and candid
honesty, award-winning freelance writer Kristine muses on life in a chaotic
household. Spoiler Alert: her teen, tweens and dog don’t find her even mildly
amusing.
My Views from the
Edge
A former comedy writer/comic for WNBC Radio in Manhattan, Elizabeth promises to
keep her advice solid and her tongue lodged securely in her cheek.
Second Life
After divorce, a death, a mid-life crisis, or just growing up and changing,
baby boomers are learning to reinvent themselves, have fun and find
satisfaction. Look out kids…it’s a new world out there!
Class Notes: Special
Needs
Learn from the journey of Jacque Digieso who was given a challenge and a
blessing with her son, who has special needs.
What's Eating
You?
Dina Zeckhausen, Ph.D. on food, weight, body image and raising resilient
kids.
Steve
Powell
Steve is an experienced facilitator, practitioner, communicator and proven
leader with over 25-years in experience in human factors education and teamwork
training.
Living On
Purpose
Elaine Taylor-Klaus, teaches how to make life extraordinary.
rWorld
Dale Kuehne explores developing a world where relationships come first, and
recognizes that individual health and fulfillment is connected to the quality
of our relationships.
Back On
Top
Ginger Emas walks through life after divorce and how you can put your best
assets forward.
Teacher
Feature
School teacher Margaret Anderson will provide insight into what really happens
with your child in the classroom.
The Sex
Whisperer
Tinamarie muses on intimacy, sensuality and conscious love with an open mind
and irreverent sense of humor.
The Power of
Grief
Diane Snyder Cowan specializes in grief therapy to help those in need deal with
loss.
Cancer is Not Me and I
Am Not My Cancer
My name is Jan Jaben-Eilon and I am an ovarian cancer survivor. I don’t like
the expression, battling with cancer. I am living my life as fully and
passionately as possible, despite the cancer. Cancer is NOT my identity.