Loading...
Jan 16

God didn't write the Bible, thank God.

Sun 16 Jan 2011 17:56:52 | 2 comments

When we were children, and somebody opened a Bible for us, we didn’t have to worry much about where the words fit in history. So, Adam and Eve came into our lives through the lovely garden. Noah collected the animals, two by two, and it rained long enough for the ark to float for 40 days. Moses climbed up Mt. Sinai and received two tablets of the Law. God parted the Red Sea so the Israelites could flee to freedom; the Egyptians drowned in their own chariots.

 

On that last one, even the Jewish fundamentalists admonish us to feel the anguish of the Egyptians—“for they were also God’s children.”   So much for God being the author, if the pious must edit.

 

This is not to mention the two consecutive conflicting accounts of Creation, the significant pattern of chronological mistakes, the clear differences in writing style that permeate the text. Deuteronomy reads a lot like Isaiah (who lived much later); the Gospels have a slew of variances in terms of narrative and detail.

 

Men and women inspired by God wrote these stirring and sacred stories that need moral follow-through much more than factual verification.

 

As Time Magazine correctly asserted in a recent piece, the greatest combined tribunal of scientific and archeological experts would never be able to conclusively prove either the burning bush incident of Moses or the resurrection of Jesus.   

 

Thank God! I don’t want the most sublime literature to have been imported to earth from heaven. Why can’t folks feel comfortable—no, feel exalted—by the notion that God didn’t write the Bible?  Men and women inspired by God wrote these stirring and sacred stories that need moral follow-through more than factual verification.

 

Why would God create a world in which there is no poetry, no imagination, no healthy rebellion and spirit in the souls of people? Don’t get stuck on the divine authorship; let your reaction and good works to these holy dramas be divine. Remember how the human soul works: The power of story transcends the literal value of what is being told or taught.

 

People need instructive legends to help religion fly (without anybody getting hurt)—this has been true from Egypt to Greece to Israel to Rome to America. If we accept, as grownups, that George Washington probably did not cut down a cherry tree, but still accept the national fatherhood of our first president, why would we accord less to Moses the lawgiver or to David the King or to Deborah the prophet-commander?

 

Whether or not Moses actually made footprints on Sinai takes nothing away from what Sinai teaches us. Whether or not David composed all of the Psalms takes nothing away from their rhapsody, their painful beauty, their healing consolation. God is my help, not my author. I give human beings too much credit for creativity, ideas, anger, and reconciliation to make us all into robots when it comes to the most venerated literature of all time!

 

Did the Bible really happen? Better to make sure it is simply happening.

 

Ben Kamin is one of America's best known rabbis, a multicultural spiritualist, NYT Op-ed contributor and author of seven books, including his latest, "NOTHING LIKE SUNSHINE: A Story in the Aftermath of the MLK Assassination."  He is a regular ShareWIK.com columnist. To find out more about Ben, go to: www.benkamin.com.

More Ben Kamin articles, click here

 

©2011 ShareWIK Media Group, LLC

  • SHARE
©2011 ShareWIK Media Group, LLC. All rights reserved. ShareWIK does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. For more information, please read our Additional Information, Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

home | sitemapfaq | columnists | members | discussions | groups | videos | press | advertise | contact us | estore | share your story | topics | calendar

Comments

This is such a beautifully written piece tackling an age old discussion concisely and poetically. I am glad I woke up to your piece this morning. Thank you.
The God of the Old Testament made a covenant with the people and passed on the laws to them. Like any parent, we do call Him "Father", when you don't follow the rules, there are consequences; hence the Egyptians and others who chose to ignore him commands. The God of the New Testament, Jesus Christ the Messiah, made a new covenant with the people based on Love. He constantly reminds us to "Love one another". It's the same God, the same message, passed on by Him, the author and perfector of our faith, to the scribes. Faith is believing without seeing. Without that, it's not faith. I agree that we need to live the messages of the Bible but I also believe that it happened as written.



or
CAPTCHA Images

Search ShareWIK

Loading

Facebook




Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Enter email below to receive our free eNewsletter
For Email Newsletters you can trust

Twitter

Latest Columns

The Grass Is Greener Right Here
With her trademark wisdom, humor and honesty, Diana Keough provides a spiritual antidote to anxiety and despair in increasingly fraught times.

Ben KaminSpirit Behind the News
Ben Kamin is one of America's best-known rabbis, a multi-cultural spiritualist, New York Times Op-ed contributor, national columnist, and the author of seven books on human values. His kids, however, are not that impressed.

I Kid You Not
With a self-deprecating sense of humor, a dash of Midwest sarcasm, and candid honesty, award-winning freelance writer Kristine muses on life in a chaotic household. Spoiler Alert: her teen, tweens and dog don’t find her even mildly amusing.

Susanne KatzSecond Life
After divorce, a death, a mid-life crisis, or just growing up and changing, baby boomers are learning to reinvent themselves, have fun and find satisfaction. Look out kids…it’s a new world out there!
Class Notes: Special Needs
Learn from the journey of Jacque Digieso who was given a challenge and a blessing with her son, who has special needs.

What's Eating You?
Dina Zeckhausen, Ph.D. on food, weight, body image and raising resilient kids.

Steve Powell
Steve is an experienced facilitator, practitioner, communicator and proven leader with over 25-years in experience in human factors education and teamwork training.
Living On Purpose
Elaine Taylor-Klaus, teaches how to make life extraordinary.
rWorld
Dale Kuehne explores developing a world where relationships come first, and recognizes that individual health and fulfillment is connected to the quality of our relationships.
Back On Top
Ginger Emas walks through life after divorce and how you can put your best assets forward.
Teacher Feature
School teacher Margaret Anderson will provide insight into what really happens with your child in the classroom.
The Power of Grief
Diane Snyder Cowan specializes in grief therapy to help those in need deal with loss.
Jan Jaben-Eilon Cancer is Not Me and I Am Not My Cancer
My name is Jan Jaben-Eilon and I am an ovarian cancer survivor. I don’t like the expression, battling with cancer. I am living my life as fully and passionately as possible, despite the cancer. Cancer is NOT my identity.

Latest Activity

posted a new blog entry We Need Fewer Flags and More Spirit.
1 day ago
posted a new blog entry We need fewer flags and more spirit.
1 day ago
posted a new blog entry .
1 day ago
posted a new blog entry Questions Men Ask About Sex.
1 day ago